Comparing Different Cat Tree Materials: Wood, Plush, or Cardboard?


If you’re shopping for a cat tree in Australia, you’ll quickly notice one thing: material matters a lot more than most people realise.

At first glance, many cat trees look similar—platforms, scratching posts, maybe a condo or hammock. But what they’re made from can dramatically affect:

  • How long the cat tree lasts

  • Whether your cat actually uses it

  • How easy it is to clean

  • How it looks in your home

  • Whether it suits Australian lifestyles and indoor living

So, how do you choose between wood, plush-covered, or cardboard cat trees?

In this in-depth guide, we’ll compare the pros and cons of each material, explain which cats they suit best, and show why many Aussie cat owners are now leaning towards solid wood and mixed-material designs for long-term value.

We’ll also highlight a few best-selling options from Cat Tree Haven, a local store specialising in well-designed cat trees made for modern Australian homes.

Why Cat Tree Material Is So Important

Cats don’t just “use” furniture—they interact with it constantly. They scratch it, jump on it, sleep on it, and rub their scent all over it.

The wrong material can lead to:

  • Cats ignoring the tree completely

  • Fast wear and tear

  • Trapped fur, odours, and allergens

  • A bulky look that clashes with your interior

Choosing the right material means your cat tree becomes a daily-used, long-term investment, not a dusty corner piece.

Option 1: Wooden Cat Trees – Durable, Stylish & Long-Lasting

What Are Wooden Cat Trees?

Wooden cat trees use solid or engineered wood for the main structure, often paired with:

  • Sisal-wrapped scratching posts

  • Cushioned platforms or condos

  • Hammocks or capsule beds

They are becoming increasingly popular in Australia—and for good reason.

Pros of Wooden Cat Trees

1. Excellent durability
Solid wood frames are far more stable than lightweight alternatives. They handle jumping, climbing, and zoomies with ease—especially important for larger cats or multi-cat households.

2. Better stability and safety
Wooden bases are heavier, reducing wobble. Cats trust furniture that doesn’t move under them.

3. Modern, furniture-like appearance
Wood blends beautifully into Australian homes that favour neutral tones, open-plan living, and minimal clutter.

4. Easier to clean
Wood surfaces don’t trap fur and odours like plush. A quick wipe-down goes a long way.

5. Long-term value
While wooden cat trees may cost more upfront, they often last years longer than plush or cardboard alternatives.

Cons of Wooden Cat Trees

  • Slightly higher initial cost

  • Heavier to move once assembled

For most Aussie households, these are small trade-offs for longevity and aesthetics.

Best Wooden Cat Tree Picks

If you’re looking to invest in wood, these are standout options:

You can explore more similar designs in the Cat Tree Haven cat tree collection

Option 2: Plush-Covered Cat Trees – Soft, Affordable & Familiar

What Are Plush Cat Trees?

Plush cat trees are usually made from:

  • A lightweight timber or MDF frame

  • Fully covered in soft fabric or faux fur

  • Sisal-wrapped scratching posts

They’re one of the most common types on the market.

Pros of Plush Cat Trees

1. Soft and cosy
Many cats enjoy plush textures for sleeping, especially in cooler climates or during winter.

2. Lower upfront cost
Plush cat trees are often cheaper, making them appealing for first-time buyers.

3. Easy for kittens and gentle climbers
The softer surface can feel less intimidating for young or timid cats.

Cons of Plush Cat Trees

1. Harder to keep clean
Plush fabric traps fur, dust, and smells—especially in warmer Australian weather.

2. Faster wear and tear
Scratching and regular use can flatten fabric and expose internal materials quickly.

3. Less visually appealing over time
Once plush starts to mat or fade, the tree can look tired and messy.

4. Lighter and less stable
Some plush trees wobble more, which can discourage confident cats from using them.

When Plush Still Makes Sense

Plush can work well when:

  • You have a single, smaller cat

  • You want something softer for sleeping

  • You’re happy to replace it after a few years

A good example of a balanced plush-and-structure design is the
160cm Tall Multi-Level Cat Tree Tower with Condo, Hammock & Scratching Posts.
It offers:

  • Height and multiple platforms

  • Enclosed and open resting areas

  • A more structured design than basic plush trees

Option 3: Cardboard Cat Trees – Lightweight & Short-Term

What Are Cardboard Cat Trees?

Cardboard cat furniture is usually:

  • Made from corrugated cardboard

  • Lightweight and recyclable

  • Designed mainly for scratching

They’re often marketed as eco-friendly or minimalist.

Pros of Cardboard Cat Trees

1. Cats love scratching cardboard
The texture is very appealing for claws.

2. Lightweight and easy to move
Good for small spaces or temporary setups.

3. Affordable
Often cheaper than full cat trees.

Cons of Cardboard Cat Trees

1. Very limited lifespan
Cardboard wears out quickly—sometimes within months.

2. Not suitable for climbing
They don’t provide real vertical space or stability.

3. Mess and debris
Scratching creates cardboard dust and fragments.

4. Limited comfort
They’re usually scratchers, not loungers or sleeping spots.

Best Use for Cardboard

Cardboard works best as:

  • A supplementary scratcher

  • A temporary solution

  • An extra scratching surface alongside a proper cat tree

It’s rarely a complete replacement for a full cat tree in Australian indoor homes.

Which Material Is Best for Australian Homes?

Here’s a simple breakdown:

  • Wood → Best for durability, style, multi-cat homes, and long-term value

  • Plush → Best for softness, comfort, and budget-conscious buyers

  • Cardboard → Best as an add-on scratcher, not a main structure

For most indoor cats in Australia—especially those living in apartments or shared family spaces—a wooden or mixed-material cat tree offers the best balance of function and aesthetics.

Why Many Aussie Owners Choose Cat Tree Haven

Australian cat owners are increasingly looking for:

  • Sturdy construction

  • Modern, furniture-like designs

  • Cat trees that don’t dominate the room

  • Materials that suit local lifestyles

That’s why stores like Cat Tree Haven focus on:

  • Solid wood frames

  • Thoughtful layouts

  • A mix of scratching, lounging, and hiding spaces

  • Designs that feel intentional, not bulky

Whether you’re browsing the full cat tree collection or comparing specific models, choosing quality materials upfront often saves money—and frustration—down the line.

Final Thoughts: Choose Material With Intention

A cat tree isn’t just pet furniture. It’s part of your home, your cat’s territory, and their daily routine.

When comparing wood, plush, or cardboard, think about:

  • Your cat’s personality and habits

  • How long you want the tree to last

  • How it will look in your living space

  • How easy it will be to maintain

For many Australian households, wooden and hybrid cat trees provide the best overall experience—for cats and humans alike.

Choose wisely, and your cat tree won’t just be used—it’ll be loved

Back to blog